On March 2, 2024, the Phantoms returned to Trinity Health Arena for a Black vs. Gray game at the home of the USHL's Muskegon Lumberjacks.  The Phantoms raised the bar to the highest level yet in Muskegon with Lee Andrews serving a Public Address Announcer, Jeremy Bos as Music DJ and honorary coaches Ezra Gennelo and Nick Howard.  During the 'Battle at the House that Walker Built', Team Gray would capture a pair of goals in the first, three goals in the middle period and four goals in third period to overtake Team Black by the final of 9-4.  Brad Zehr (Black) and Trent Kik (Gray) would serve as captains for the event.  Kyle Steinke would be game photographers.  Walt Clarke and Brian Ostwald would be the referees for the tilt.  Following the Black vs. Gray game, the group with 90 tickets will watch as the Muskegon Lumberjacks would defeat the Waterloo Blackhawks 5-2.